Skip to content
← Hull Matchday

Michael Owen says Hull City shouldn’t have been promoted to Premier League

Michael Owen says Hull City shouldn’t have been promoted to Premier League

The upcoming Premier League campaign is mere days away, and ahead of the opening fixtures, numerous commentators have dismissed Hull City’s chances and expect the club to make a swift return to the second tier.

Just as they were a year prior when the club was forecast to drop to League One, the Tigers face widespread scepticism from former professionals and analysts alike regarding their survival prospects.

Head coach Sergej Jakirovic and his squad will likely welcome such predictions, embracing their status as perhaps the division’s most significant underdogs since Luton Town’s recent top-flight stint.

Here follows a summary of expert opinions on the Tigers ahead of this weekend’s season opener.

Michael Owen suggested Hull represented the obvious candidates for relegation, questioning whether they should have earned promotion at all. He acknowledged his television work requires attention to statistics and data, yet pointed out that according to the metrics employed by analysts, Hull ought not to have finished in the Championship’s upper half last term, making their advancement an exceptional overachievement.

Glen Johnson observed that promoted clubs face enormous difficulties sustaining Premier League status nowadays, explaining why such sides frequently find themselves favourites for the drop. He noted Sunderland’s success the previous campaign demonstrated that prudent investment can defy expectations and secure survival. Johnson characterised the Premier League as comprising three distinct groups: the leading six clubs, the bottom six, and an eight-team middle tier. He believed Hull could draw encouragement from last season, which illustrated how five or six sides could easily have suffered relegation, meaning survival only requires outpacing three rivals. His recommendation for Hull involved making several calculated signings of players familiar with the league who could inject top-flight experience into the dressing room, suggesting older individuals posed no issue as short-term contracts would suffice. Johnson stressed the subsequent priority must be acquiring someone capable of breaching resilient defences, since Hull would likely concede more frequently than the previous campaign, making goalscoring the essential focus. Sunderland’s astute summer recruitment had set the benchmark for first-season survival, which promoted clubs should attempt to replicate, though the task would always prove demanding.

Don Goodman noted Hull occupied an almost identical position to Sunderland twelve months earlier, with widespread pessimism pervading football circles before a ball had been kicked. Nobody had genuinely anticipated Sunderland’s survival prospects following their play-off final triumph over Sheffield United, making similar scepticism towards Hull entirely unsurprising. While the club had secured signings including Matt Target and Jack Butland, Goodman insisted a ruthless strategy remained essential despite potential harshness towards the squad that achieved promotion. Such an approach became unavoidable for those seeking to compete at the highest level. Sunderland, Leeds, and Burnley had all demonstrated ruthlessness when overhauling their squads upon promotion, and this provided the clearest path to any realistic survival hopes. Sentiment must be shelved in favour of recruiting individuals capable of immediately elevating standards. Hull faced an enormous undertaking against formidable obstacles, though Goodman anticipated significant transfer activity before the window closed, with numerous arrivals and departures expected at the club.

Alan Hutton suggested Troy Parrott ought to consider the three clubs freshly promoted to the Premier League, as these sides required goalscoring contributions more urgently than any others to preserve their top-flight standing. Parrott would join any of them as an immediate starter, ready to make an instant impact. Hutton reminded observers not to overlook Parrott’s complete skillset, describing him as a versatile forward whose contribution extended beyond mere goalscoring, encompassing attacking runs, explosive speed, and the ability to hold up play. These qualities proved essential for any striker tasked with keeping a newly-promoted club in the Premier League. The decision ultimately hinged on maximising playing opportunities, and while a move to a higher-placed club might appeal, Hutton believed Parrott currently required a situation guaranteeing regular first-team football.

Pat Nevin admitted concerns existed regarding Coventry, Hull, and Ipswich, acknowledging that adjustment following promotion always proved challenging. He expressed particular optimism for Coventry, citing Frank’s influence and their impressive previous campaign under his guidance. Nevertheless, the leap to Premier League standard remained substantial, though not unachievable, with Sunderland having illustrated the feasibility of survival. Ipswich confronted a stern test given their historical context, requiring patience before drawing conclusions. Nevin anticipated attending Coventry’s fixture against Hull and was eager to observe both teams competitively. Hull specifically faced a formidable challenge, having finished sixth the previous term before navigating the playoffs, a process demanding considerable effort before confronting Premier League demands. Some apprehension existed, with these three clubs potentially constituting the primary candidates for immediate relegation. Yet this did not guarantee their fate, and should even one survive, that would represent achievement given the division’s unforgiving nature.